|
Notes from Gedatsukai - 2001
Shimpan Class
Ando Sensei
Submitted by Lawrence Chun (ed. DYT)
September 20, 2001
1.Most important thing is to be aware of a good yuko-datotsu.
2.Yuko-datotsu, should decide the match.
3.KI-KEN-TAI no itchi is the most important factor in determining a
yuko-datotsu.
a.If a player stumbles on his hakama and delivers a strike he is
missing the tai so no point should be awarded
b.If a players hand slips off his shinai at the moment a strike is
made the ken is missing so no point should be awarded.
c.If an opponent destroys a players zanshin with a hard shove, the
player who hit a good yuko-datotsu must be awarded the point. If not,
players will use this strategy continuously and the match will end up
a
brawl instead of a Kendo shiai. Teachers were asked to stress this among
their students.***
4.Shimpan should not debate the rules. If a referee is unfamiliar with
the
rules, not only it is embarrassing, it creates unnecessary problems
for
players, coaches and spectators.
5.Gogi is to clear up any uncertainty. It is not a time to discuss the
rules.
6.It was stressed that may times the wrong player wins the match.
a.Referees call was incorrect -- no yuko-datotsu was delivered.
b.Shinai did not contact the datotsu-bui area, or worse, the
referee does not the proper datotsu-bui area.
c.Player did not strike with the monouchi (datotsu-bu). Special
concern was given to the do strike.
d.Referee saw the point but did not react and now cannot award a
point without creating a controversy. Referee was not paying enough
attention to see a quick waza and yuko-datotsu.
e.Referee does not have enough experience and is unaware of a waza
or is not comfortable with a particular yuko-datotsu. Specifically,
hidari
kote, hidari-do, tsuki.
f.Referee does not have enough practical Kendo experience to
recognize a good hit. Because the strike took place on the opposite
side
of his vantage point he constantly flags, I did not see. Ando Sensei
stressed that one must identify simply by the position of the player
and
shinai, along with the sound of the strike whether the hit was a yuko
datotsu or not.
g.Referees become too preoccupied with their own prejudices that
they fail to call the match properly. e.g. A Sensei who stresses zanshin
may never award a point unless he is 100% satisfied. This is unrealistic.
The sensei is judging a shiai, not conducting practice.
h.Referees who raise flags too early to too late create confusion
between the players.
i.Referees who are not experienced enough to understand the level
of the players they are watching. They must take into account the age
and
skill level of the players. Referees must consider this carefully.
7.Shimpan need to practice Kendo diligently in order to properly call
a
yuko-datotsu. Suriage waza is difficult to see because of the speed
involved. Only experienced Kendoist can clearly see these techniques.
8.Experience is also important to anticipate the movements of the players.
This is necessary when moving around the court. Before changing positions
the referee must sense that there is no attempt at a waza being made.
9.Ando Sensei stressed that the appearance of impartiality is vital
for a
fair contest. Shimpan who are waiting to enter the court must not be
cheering for their teammates or students. They must wait quietly and
patiently on the sidelines. This also applies to the people on the scorers
table.
10.Each shimpan should make a quick visual inspection of the player
that
is closest to him before the match begins. Check all ties, tasuki
(mejirushi) color, and condition of the shinai.
11.Signals from all shimpan must be crisp and clear. The shushin must
control the actions and calls of all situations on the court. If necessary
he must stop the match to clear up any ambiguous calls. There must be
no
confusion.
12.When referees switch positions around the court it is not necessary
to
hold the red flag on the outside.
13.If a player holds his kamae in jodan the shimpan must adjust to the
situation and move toward the player in chudan no kamae in order to
obtain
a clear view of the tsuki area of the jodan player. If both players
are in
jodan shimpan should take a step or two backward in order to see both
players with a better perspective.
14.Moving around the court was discussed and the diagram that Ando Sensei
used was different from what I was accustomed to seeing. [Diagram:
diagonal lines from opposite corners divide the court into 4
right-triangles] Each fukushin is responsible for each diagonal half.
The
shushins movement can cover 3/4 of the court if necessary.
15.Tsubazeriai was discussed at length
a.Proper tsubazeriai was the most significant topic. All referees
must know the proper stance of each player as well as shinai position.
The
blade of your opponents sword must be over your left shoulder -- this
will
prevent your neck from being cut. Both players should not be shoving
each
other. A strong push to start hiki-waza is acceptable.
b.Proper zanshin in hiki-waza is important to determine
yuko-datotsu.
c.After an attack, many players automatically go into tsubazeriai.
This must be discouraged. The proper attitude is to attack until a
definite yuko-datotsu is made. Taiatari, ni-dan and san-dan waza are
the
proper courses of action. This must be emphasized to students.
d.Referees should temper the use of wakare. The shimpan must allow
players to opportunity to set up a waza. Calling too quickly will
discourage any attempts. Players will simply wait for the shushin to
call
wakare. If a player is deliberately trying to tie up the other or
stalling, hansoku should be given instead of calling wakare.
**** Ando Sensei asked the foreign leaders to carefully consider what
they
were teaching. He mentioned that the future of Kendo would be determined
by the teachers of today. If we stress winning shiai, Kendo will evolve
into nothing more than a sport. Stretching the rules in order to win
a
match demeans the integrity of the Shimpan, players and Kendo.
He believes that shiai represents a duel between gentlemen. If a person
imagines real swords being used, an insightful appreciation of Kendo
can
be realized. The rough style of Kendo, such as shoving your opponent
after
a hit to break his zanshin or charging into a smaller opponent in an
attempt to intimidate him, is unrealistic in a real duel. There could
be
no shoving, as the man would be dead. Charging foolishly into an opponents
sword will produce the same results.
He cautioned us by saying a teacher will influence their students with
their own philosophies. We can continue to perpetuate productive ladies
and gentlemen. Or, we can produce a competitive brute, who intentionally
hurt people and bend the rules, all under the pretence of Kendo.
Return to top of page
EXPERIENCE ACHIEVED DURING THE GEDATSU-KAI TRAINING
July 27 through August 3, 2001
A Report to the Hawaii Kendo Federation
By David Hilo Kikau, Jr.
The purpose of this report is to share the experience I achieved during
the Gedatsu-kai Summer Training, July 27 through August 3, 2001. First,
I
come to realize after training in Kendo for thirty-one years that training
in Kendo must have clear goals. Second, to sustain the basics I
experienced at Gedatsu-kai, the technique must be practiced over and
over
if I am to make the techniques, I learned, my own. Finally, defeating
the
opponent is not Kendo, defeating myself to achieve perfect kendo technique
and being an accountable Kendo instructor and citizen is the essence
of
Kendo today.
Clear Goals:
Kendoist in Hawaii, as I myself, must have clear goals that are achievable
and measurable. Why do I train in Kendo? I train in Kendo because I
love
it. I now realize that the movements required in Kendo are complicated
because they must all conform to the actions of an opponent. I believe
this means that Kendo demands a wide variety of kinds of training, which
differ from each other in terms of technique and physical strength.
I have
always believed that the ultimate goal in Kendo is high. I was lead
to
believe having courage to defeat myself and an opponent was why I trained
in Kendo. I have returned from Japan realizing that to achieve true
Kendo,
through proper practice and guidance by good to great instructors,
requires overlapping goals. Personally I believed some of these
overlapping goals were family, health, country, and God. At Gedatsu-kai,
through outstanding Kendo Instructors such as Kudoshi Sensei, Tomita
Sensei, and Okabe Sensei (excuse me if spelling is in error), I learn
that
overlapping goals are continuous training in the following areas:
Ippon-Uchi-No-Waza (Kihon-Uchi -- basic strikes and thrusts skills)
Harai Waza (warding off techniques)
Debana-Waza (techniques that exploit the advantage of the opponents
attack)
Hiki-Waza (step-back techniques)
Oji-Waza (parry and counterattack)
All Japan Kendo Kata
Shinpan practice
I realize to sustain 10% of what I have learned, I must make the above
mentioned my present goals to be a better Kendoist and perhaps achieve
my
Roku-Dan in my next attempt.
Repeated Practice:
It was made clear that even a simple technique must be practiced over
and
over again if I want a technique to be my own. It was clear to me that
even advanced techniques (Wazas) demand continuous training. The bottom
line up front is that in order to master a technique, I have to practice
it until it is a reflex. I feel comfortable to say I have mastered at
least three Wazas over the years. To improve my Kendo to a Roku-Dan
caliber, I must master at least ten Wazas.
Currently in Hawaii the Kendo instructors are doing what is right with
the
young Kendoist by practicing the basic Wazas and stressing the importance
of repeated practice.
A Reality Check on My Kendo:
I did not achieve my Roku-Dan because I was not worthy of being promoted.
During the practices I felt confident of my ability to attack, counter
attack, parry attack and parry counter attack. After failing the Dan
examination, I was approached by a number os Senseis who informed me
that
I was too aggressive in my technique and that I failed to demonstrate
clean, controlled Sen Sen No Sen (win by anticipating the partners
initiative) and I hit too many times.
Until this experience, I was lead to believe Kendo to be an aggressive
art
where initiative and Ki-Ken-Tai and Datotsu were required. I now realize
that in order for me to achieve my Roku-Dan, I must improve in Sen Sen
No
Sen and avoid being too aggressive. I need to force myself to observe
my
opponent and to anticipate the opponents initiative so I can hit first,
counter, or move and parry with a counter attack.
I look forward on continuing to improve my Kendo with the Hawaii Kendo
Federation. As a leader, I realize that I must lead by an example through
my Kendo Waza and my demeanor during practices and tournaments.
The greatest lesson learned at Gedatsu-kai has been the realization
that
it is vitally important to practice the basic movements and to develop
the
ability to alter my movements freely in conformity with the actions
of
the opponent without being too aggressive.
This report is submitted for the perusal by the Kendoist of Hawaii
with
hope that you learn from my experience.
Return to top of page
Essay for Kenkyukai (July-August, 2001)
By Takuma Hirako
In Kenkyukai, for the last two months, I've learned some Kendo phrases
and
terms. most of them were very difficult to understand. However, most
of
the phrases were very interesting. Out of all the phrases, I am going
to
write about three phrases that were most interesting to me. They are
"Sandan no Ma," "Gogyo no Kamae," and "Kou
Ken Chi Ai."
First, "Sandan no Ma." I knew that there are three kinds
of Ma, but I
didn't know what Ge-dan no Kamae really looked like. Also, I always
hit
from Chikama so I'm trying to hit from Tooma. I think the distance is
important, because when you stay in Tooma, usually they won't hit you,
but
it is harder for me to hit, too. However, although Chikama is easier
to
hit, it is also easier for your opponent to hit, too. Therefore I am
trying to hit from Tooma.
Secondly, "Gogyo no Kamae" was very interesting to me. It
is because I
didn't know that there were symbols that represent each of the Kamae.
I
also learned that each Kamae has a weakness. I thought all the Kamae
were
the same. I also learned that Hassou and Waki Gamae were only for Kendo
Kata. I knew that the Seigan no Kamae had five places to point. However
I
was also surprised that even those five directions also had symbols.
Lastly I thought "Kou Ken Chi Ai" was very important. Especially
before
and after Shiai or practicing. I think making friends with Kendo is
important because I think it helps me to get better by thinking that
I am
going to get better than my friends or beat them in tournament even
though
I'd lost to them on the last tournament. Also when someone comes from
Japan to practice, it's good to be friends with him or her. Also when
I go
back to Japan for vacation, I could go see them.
I had more things that were interesting to me. I also had a lot of
things
that I didn't know about. I will try to learn little by little and
remember and understand all of the phrases/terms from the Kenkyukai
in
July and August.
Return to top of page
May 4, 2001
By Lawrence Chun
Kenyukai practice on May 4, 2001 was conducted by both Teshima Sensei
and
Ueno Sensei. Shiai and Simpan scenarios were the main topic of discussion.
The main scenarios were as follows:
1. Regarding judging of different ranks from children to Yudansha.
Although the rule book specifically states that a good Yuko-datotsu
must
be delivered for a point to be scored it is within each judge's discretion
to allow a point depending on the age and ability of the players. Each
judge should have enough sense as well as experience to make calls in
relation to the players ability.
2. Unnecessary roughness-Boryoku-was also discussed. The most common
scenario is when a player wrestles his opponent out of the Shiai-jo.
The
Shimpan must note if it was part of the normal course of events or not.
If
so then the player who stepped out is given a Hansoku. If a player is
merely trying to push and shove his opponent out of the Shiai-jo with
no
intention of delivering a strike, Hansoku will be given to that player
for
unnecessary roughness.
3. Rule about injury was also brought up. Section 2 Article 30 of the
IKF
rule book (page 16) states: "In case Shiai-sha is unable to continue
Shiai
due to an injury, should the opponent be deemed responsible for the
accident, whether intentionally or not, the opponent shall lose Shiai."
According to Mr. Teshima this passage is incorrectly translated from
Japanese. Its correct translation does not include the phrase "whether
intentionally or not." This rule has been interpreted literally
by HKF in
its tournaments and I believe other English speaking countries have
also
interpreted this rule incorrectly. Perhaps this should be brought to
the
attention of the Shiai Rule's Committee for clarification.
[note from DYT: the intention of the rule here seems to be to penalize
the
offender of the injury. If the injury was caused intentionally or by
negligence, the offender loses. The term Kashitsu is translated as
accident, fault, mistake, blunder. But, it is also possible that the
injured was actually negligent. For example, if an injury occured after
a
Taiatari, judges must determine if the Taiatari was done properly or
if it
was received properly. So, rather than "accident," terms like
"mistake" or
"blunder" might be a more accurate for this section. Second
part of the
rule states that if the cause cannot be assertained, then the Shiai
Funo
Sha (injured) will be the loser.]
4. Overwhelming an opponent because of size and strength was also
discussed. Although no particular rule covers this area it is strongly
recommended that Sensei's advise their players against deliberately
trying
to hurt their opponent by using their physical power.
5. During a Shiai, if a player is over exuberant and continually knocks
down their opponent this may interpreted as unnecessary roughness. The
player is within the rules but the judges may see it differently and
all
players must be sensitive to the situation of the moment.
6. Mr. Sato mentioned that the best Shiai's are usually determined
by the
performance of the judges. For example, all Shimpan moves in accordance
with one another. When a point is scored all flags come up together
and
immediately. Finally all commands and instructions are clear and concise.
The judges do not command the match, they command the respect of the
players and spectators. By doing so, it allows the players to perform
their best Kendo
Return to top of page.
April 6, 2001
Mr. Carl Nakamura led the participants through Suriage Waza during
the
September 1 meeting. Proper use of Shinogi, Ashi Sabaki, Tenouchi were
emphasized.
March 2, 2001
By Jack Yamada
On March 2nd, we had to learn about Miyamoto Musashi. (This session
was
led by Mr. Katsumi Yamada.) He had something like Earth, Sky, Wind,
Water,
and Fire (in the Book of Five Rings -- Gorin No Sho). We had to hear
about
the Earth part, and had to learn how to use one Katana and using the
sword.
April 7, 2000
By the Chun family
Since April 2000, Teshima Sensei has been leading special sessions
(approximately one-half hour in length) before regular practice on Sunday
mornings at the
Kaimuki gym. Sessions in April concentrated on the basics -- including
Kendo etiquette (the Rei before entering the Dojo, Ritsurei, Zarei,
how to
sit and stand up properly) and footwork.
During the month of May, these sessions focused on Kata. The first
three
Ohdachi forms were reviewed and practiced on the first Sunday, followed
by
the remaining four forms the next week. The three Kodachi forms were
also
studied on the third Sunday, eliminating in the complete Nihon Kendo
Kata
on the last Sunday, as would
be demonstrated during an actual Kyu/Dan examination. Also during the
last
Sunday of May was a very interesting and informative presentation of
Japanese swords by Dr. Tokeshi. He explained in detail the various parts,
the method in which one is made, the different types, maintenance and
handling, as well as the historic background, of Japanese swords. Most
impressive were the beautiful swords that he brought with him.
The Kyu/Dan examinations are rapidly approaching and as a result, on
June
4th (the first session of the new month), Murakami Sensei graciously
shared his thoughts on how to carry oneself during such an examination.
He
stressed arriving prepared with the proper attitude, which should continue
throughout the entire testing period. Akagi Sensei also added insight
when
he highlighted what he looks for as one the examiners. In preparation
for
the upcoming tournaments during the next few months, attention then
shifted to Shimpan practice for Kenshi 3-dan and up (Kenshi 2-dan and
below
provide the participants for the Shiai being judged), and will continue
to
do through the rest of June.
February 4, 2000
By Andy Fujimoto
Every first Friday of the month the yudansha kenshi get together and
have
practice among themselves at the Japanese Cultural Center. These practices
are focused on
helping younger, as well as older, kenshis to improve themselves, their
kata and kendo. This past practice on February 4, was a very good
practice. I got to learn and brush up on my kata (numbers 5-7) and had
a
very strenuous practice after the Kata. In the beginning of practice
we
got to ask questions, and I learn a lot through this question and answer
time. Then we went over the kata. We take each kata step by step and
brush
up on the things we forget. After about thirty minutes of kata we put
on
our dogu and get into practice. During practice I also learn a lot such
as
trying to fight more like a yudansha. The practice lasts about thirty
minutes. Every time I go home after practice I feel that I have learned
something new after this practice so I could try to better myself.
October 2002 Kenkyukai
By Akiko Furutani
For this month's Kenkyukai, Mr. Seth Harris led a session on Fudochi
Shimmyo Roku written by Takuan Soho. Although I must admit that a lot
the
things discussed were matters far beyond my knowledge, there were a
few
concepts that I understood a little and these left me to think about
them.
The discussion about the Kannon Bosatsu, the Buddha with 1,000 arms
was
one of them. Mr. Harris pointed out that if the Buddha were to focus
on
just one arm, then the rest of the nine hundred ninety-nine of the arms
would be useless and wasted. Another one was the passage about the leaf
on
the tree. If one focuses on just that one leaf, then one will fail to
notice the rest of the leaves on the tree. I thought that these points
were interesting because it is something that is seemingly simple, yet
something that I think a lot of people take for granted.
Zengo Sai Dan, from what I understand is something that means to focus
on
the present and not the future or the past. When going against someone,
it
is important to focus on the "now" and not eh before or the
after. In
other words, thing only about what is happening at the moment and not
who
else you will be fighting next or what technique worked on the particular
person before.
Ms. Akiko Furutani has graciously accepted a position as our HKF reporter.
She regularly attends all of the HKF Keiko and functions (e.g., monthly Kenkyu
Kai, Sunday General Keiko at Honbu, special Keiko with visitors) in her busy
schedule as a student at the University of Hawaii. She participated at the
recent World Kendo Championships at Glasgow as a member of Team Hawaii. Her
monthly report summarizes the activities and lists visitors to HKF, in hope
of increased participation by the HKF members in the future. [DYT]
September, 2003
By Akiko Furutani
In the beginning of this month, we were fortunate to have a group of students
from Kokushikan University lead by Baba Kinji Sensei. During their stay they
not only practiced with us but also demonstrated Sumo, Iai, and the Baba-ha
Kumitachi, a form of Kata that Baba Sensei developed when he visited Brazil
a few months ago.
At the end of the Kaimuki Honbu practice on Sunday, their last practice
with us, Baba Sensei took the time to share his comments and advice with
us. One of which was that in Kendo the left side of the body – mainly
the left arm and the left leg—is vital. He advised us to be careful
as some of us tended to have our left knees bent, thus causing our Fumikomi
to be an up and down movement instead of forward movement.
On their last night in Hawaii, we had a barbeque party at the Fort DeRussy
Park. For many of us, it was a bonding time with the Kokushikan students.
The night was spent sharing stories, wrestling in the sand, and dunking each
other into the water (including Furutani Sensei, Akiko’s father).
The Kenkyukai practice this month was held on September 5th and was led
by Teshima Sensei. We learned the All Japan Kendo Federation’s Kihon
Kendo Skills using the Bokuto. The purpose of this Kihon Kata is “to
master the basic Kendo skills, remembering that the Shinai represents the
Japanese sword, and to study the principles of the sword (Toho) and manners
(Saho), and interactions with each other using the selected Waza using the
Bokuto.”
The basic procedures of the Kihon Kata such as the footwork, Maai, Ritsurei,
etc., all follow that of Nihon Kendo Kata. The two people involved in the
Kihon Kata are the receiver called Motodachi and the trainee called the Kakarite.
There are nine fundamental Waza in the Kihon Kendo Kata:
1. Ippon Uchi No Waza (single hit): Men, Kote, Do, Tsuki
2. Nidan No Waza (double hit): Kote-Men
3. Harai Waza (sweeping up): Harai Men
4. Hiki Waza (retreating): Men-Tsubazeriai-Hiki Do
5. Nuki Waza (dodging): Men, Nuki Do
6. Suriage Waza (brushing up): Kote, Suriage Men
7. Debana Waza (thwarting): Debana Kote
8. Kaeshi Waza (turning over): Men, Kaeshi Do
9. Uchiotoshi Waza (striking down): Do, Uchiotoshi Men
Going through the fundamental Kendo skills using the Bokuto makes it apparent
when the Hasuji (blade) of the sword is incorrect. The Bokuto resembles more
closely the shape of an actual sword while the Shinai is round in shape.
Sometimes it is harder to grasp the actual concept of the idea that the Shinai
represents a sword because of the difference in shape.
Although there are only nine fundamental Waza in the actual Kata, it can
be applied to other higher technical Waza as student progresses. For example,
for Nidan No Waza, the second one in the Kata, students who have advanced
can apply it to Sandan No Waza (triple hits) such as Kote-Men-Do. In other
words, based on this fundamental Kata, students and teachers can apply it
to more Waza as they continue to advance and teach Kendo. It is very important
to have a solid foundation of basics to develop upon and this Kihon Kata
can be part of that.
|